
So yesterday, I saw the Paper Mill Playhouse's production of Disney's High School Musical with Monzi and some other people from my soccer team. It was really messed up. First of all, Troy (Chase Peacock) had spiky hair. Gabriella (Sydney Morton) looked like she was thirty, and she was kinda fat. Taylor (Krystal Joy Brown) had an afro, and (Justin Keyes) Chad didn't. Martha was an ugly midget. Jason was blonde. There was this announcer guy, Jack Scott (Joseph Morales) who wasn't in the original Disney version and he ended up going out with Kelsi (Stephanie Pam Roberts), instead of some basketball jock. The only people who looked like their characters were Bailey Hanks, playing Sharpay, and Logan Hart, playing Ryan. None of them could sing, especially not Troy and Gabriella! They changed most of the songs and costumes. Remember Sharpay's blue feathery Bop to the Top dress? It became a red tango dress. Kinda like this. And you know how Gabriella used to wear flowery dresses all the time? Well, not anymore! Also, Chad lost his basketball! Comparing it to Disney's original movie, it basically sucked. On its own, it was pretty good, if you overlook the horrible singers.
But don't just take my word for it. Listen to NJ.com's review, by Peter Filichia from the Star Ledger:
Don't forget to click all the links!!!"David Simpatico adapted the script to the stage, added a joke about nose-picking, another about flatulence, and a new character. He's Jack Scott, who broadcasts meant-to-be-amusing announcements over the P.A. system: Joseph Morales is the unfortunate actor who squeezed very few laughs from the absolutely terrible material he was saddled with at Sunday's opening.
At least Morales didn't have to compete with the memory of anyone in the movie. "High School Musical" fans will probably not take to Chase Peacock, who has dared to replicate the role of Troy, originated by Zac Efron. Peacock is an accomplished performer, but his dissimilarity to Efron will automatically make him a distant second in young people's hearts.
No such problem for Sydney Morton, who does look like her forebear, Vanessa Hudgens. She's an adorable singer and dancer, but like so many in the cast, she appears to be too old. Granted, they're not as aged as the cast of that '50s high school musical on Broadway -- which really should be called "Ancient Grease" -- but another Broadway show, "13," proves there are talented kids who truly are kids out there. In this production, most cast members mention their college educations in the program bios.
That's probably why every performer is so accomplished. Each gets every step of Denis Jones' choreography (if it can be called that; calisthenics is a better description), and director Mark S. Hoebee has drilled them into a terrific company.
As Sharpay, Bailey Hanks knows how to be evil, and Logan Hart makes Ryan more three-dimensional than his character appears on the page. Stephanie Pam Roberts, as Kelsi, grows nicely from demure to backbone-strong.
The most hateful aspect of the show is the characterization of drama teacher Ms. Darbus -- a pretentious, silly, and oh-so-grahnd easy target who refers to "football diamonds" and "basketball touchdowns." Donna English keeps the degradation to a minimum.
While all is said and sung, adults might enjoy watching these young actors knock themselves out. And perhaps the sons and daughters who made them attend will like the Paper Mill Playhouse enough to return for the next musical: "1776." Now there's a show!"
SHOUTOUT: Monica--email me the pix!!!
